In 1938 . . .
Unemployment spiked to 19 percent during a new economic recession.
Most Americans wanted to keep refugees out of the United States.
More than 100 African Americans had been lynched since 1930.
Two-thirds of Americans believed German Jews were either “entirely” or “partly” to blame for their own persecution.
Germany expanded its territory by annexing Austria in March and the Sudetenland of Czechoslovakia in September.
The peacetime US Army ranked 17th in the world, both in size and combat power.
Further Reading
The Evian Conference
The American press criticized the 32 nations attending the Evian Conference, including the United States, for their inaction. Most of the participants expressed sympathy for the refugees but offered little assistance, claiming that increased immigration might hurt their own nations’ economies. Some spoke bluntly about not wanting to admit Jews.
Time magazine concluded: “All nations present expressed sympathy for the refugees but few offered to allow them within their boundaries.”
Further Reading
The Challenges of Escape
Refugees crowd outside the US consulate in Marseilles, France, ca. 1940.
US Holocaust Memorial Museum.
On November 7, 1938, only a few days before the Kristallnacht pogrom, the US consulate issued this US immigration visa to Fritz Treuer. Nazi Germany had annexed Austria earlier that year, and the consulate was now in “Vienna, Germany.”
US Holocaust Memorial Museum.
It was very difficult to immigrate to the United States. In 1924, the US Congress passed the Johnson-Reed Act in order to set limits on the maximum number of immigrant visas that could be issued per year to people born in each country.
These quotas were designed to limit the immigration of people considered “racially undesirable,” including southern and eastern European Jews. After 1938, only 27,370 people born in Germany could immigrate to the United States each year.
Potential immigrants to the United States had to collect many types of documents, including proof of identity, police certificates, medical clearances, tax documents, a ship ticket, and exit permits prior to obtaining a visa. Most also had to find an American financial sponsor who had the resources to guarantee they would never become a burden on the United States.
The US government made no exceptions for refugees escaping persecution, and did not adjust the immigration laws in the 1930s or 1940s. The waiting lists for US immigrant visas grew as hundreds of thousands of Jews attempted to flee Europe.
Attacks on Jews Shock Americans
Nazi Party officials set off a nationwide riot against Jews in Germany and Austria on the night of November 9–10, 1938, an event known as Kristallnacht. Units of the Nazi Party’s SA militia and Hitler Youth destroyed hundreds of synagogues and thousands of Jewish-owned shops. Nearly 30,000 Jewish men were arrested and sent to concentration camps.
American newspapers covered the Nazi terror attack against Jews in banner headlines on their front pages, and articles about the events continued to appear for several weeks.
Further Reading
Public Opinion Polls after Kristallnacht
November 1938
Polls conducted several weeks after the Kristallnacht attacks found that Americans overwhelmingly disapproved of the Nazi treatment of Jews, but most did not want more Jewish refugees to immigrate to the United States.
Do you approve or disapprove of the Nazi treatment of Jews in Germany?
American Institute of Public Opinion
Should we allow a larger number of Jewish exiles from Germany to come to the United States to live?
American Institute of Public Opinion
Roosevelt Denounces Nazis
At his press conference five days after Kristallnacht, President Franklin D. Roosevelt said that the attack had “deeply shocked” the American public. He ordered the US ambassador in Germany to return home as a sign of protest and allowed 12,000 Germans—most of them Jews—who were temporarily in the United States to remain indefinitely.
“I cannot, in any decent humanity, throw them out,” he explained to reporters. But Roosevelt also said that US immigration quotas would not be changed to admit more Jewish refugees.
The White House, 1941.
Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division, Washington, DC.
Admit Refugee Children?
Sen. Robert Wagner speaks with Congresswoman Edith Nourse Rogers about their bill to welcome German refugee children. Actress Helen Hayes, who testified in support of the bill, sits in the middle.
Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division, Washington, DC.
The Non-Sectarian Committee for German Refugee Children published this brochure in support of the Wagner-Rogers bill.
American Friends Service Committee Archives, Philadelphia, PA.
In February 1939, Democratic senator Robert Wagner of New York and Republican congresswoman Edith Nourse Rogers of Massachusetts introduced legislation in Congress to admit 20,000 German refugee children under the age of 14 over a two-year period. The bill specified that the 10,000 children per year would enter the United States outside the existing restrictive immigration quota laws.
In Favor
First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt backed the Wagner-Rogers Bill, the first time that she publicly endorsed any pending legislation as first lady. Despite Mrs. Roosevelt’s urging, FDR never officially commented on the proposal to admit refugee children.
Opposed
Senator Robert Reynolds, a Democrat from North Carolina and a vocal opponent of the bill, had recently proposed banning all immigration for ten years or until the nation solved its unemployment problems. His compromise, a five-year total ban on all immigration in exchange for passing the child refugee bill, was rejected.
The American people agreed with Reynolds: 66 percent of Americans polled in January 1939 opposed expanding immigration to aid the refugee children. The Wagner-Rogers Bill never made it to a vote in Congress.
The St. Louis
On May 13, 1939, the German transatlantic liner MS St. Louis sailed from Hamburg, Germany, for Havana, Cuba, carrying 937 passengers, most of them German Jews. When the ship arrived in Havana, the passengers learned that the landing certificates they had purchased were invalid, and the Cuban government forced the St. Louis to leave its harbor. As the ship sailed toward Miami, passengers sent telegrams to loved ones and public officials in the United States pleading for assistance. But they did not have entry visas, and the US government did not allow the passengers to land.
What Happened to the St. Louis Passengers?
After the St. Louis passengers failed to find refuge in the Western Hemisphere, the ship sailed back to Europe. The American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee aid organization worked with the US State Department to persuade four countries—Great Britain, France, the Netherlands, and Belgium—to admit the passengers. One year later, many of the refugees found themselves living under Nazi occupation again, after Germany invaded multiple western European countries. Of the 937 St. Louis passengers, 254 were murdered in the Holocaust.
World War II
On September 1, 1939, Nazi Germany invaded Poland. Great Britain and France declared war two days later. President Roosevelt reassured Americans that the United States would remain neutral in World War II.
Americans clamor to see newspapers announcing the outbreak of war in Europe.
Associated Press.
Fear of Spies
FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover at his desk, Washington, DC, 1940.
Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division, Washington, DC.
The United States Office of War Information produced this poster in 1943 to warn Americans that enemy spies committing sabotage were a significant threat to national security.
US Holocaust Memorial Museum.
After the war in Europe began, warnings about spies, sometimes referred to as a “fifth column,” dominated American culture. Fears worsened in the spring of 1940 when Nazi Germany invaded and quickly defeated France, leading Americans to worry that enemy agents had brought the country down from within.
In a June 1940 poll, 72 percent of Americans believed Germany had already placed spies in the United States, and 22 percent weren’t sure.
FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover published cautionary articles in popular magazines about spies and saboteurs in the United States. In a May 1940 radio broadcast to the American public—one of his many “fireside chats”—President Roosevelt called spies a significant threat to national security.
The State Department put additional security measures in place to screen potential immigrants, making an already difficult process even harder.
Public Opinion Poll on Entering World War II
May 1940
A poll conducted one week after Nazi Germany invaded Belgium, the Netherlands, and France, showed that Americans overwhelmingly opposed entering World War II.
Do you think the United States should declare war on Germany and send our army and navy abroad to fight?
American Institute of Public Opinion
America First Committee
In 1940, a group of Yale University students founded the America First Committee to oppose US intervention in the European war. They quickly mobilized hundreds of other antiwar students to join the organization, and persuaded one of the nation’s most outspoken isolationists, Charles Lindbergh, to support its cause. Lindbergh’s enormous celebrity—dating to his 1927 solo, nonstop flight across the Atlantic Ocean—helped the America First Committee become a national organization with as many as 800,000 members.
“War Agitators”
After Lindbergh accused Jews of being “war agitators” in a speech at Des Moines, Iowa, on September 11, 1941, the America First Committee’s reputation changed significantly. Newspapers and magazines across the country denounced Lindbergh and the committee for promoting antisemitism and intolerance. Political cartoonists, including PM newspaper artist Theodor Geisel (Dr. Seuss), accused Lindbergh of spreading Nazi propaganda. America First Committee leaders denied the accusation, but the criticism continued. As soon as the United States entered World War II in December 1941, the committee disbanded.